Christopher Columbus The Consequences Of The Columbian...

On one fateful October morning, in the year 1492, the world as we knew it was changed for better or for worse. As the bow of a Spanish ship came into the sight line of a small Bahamian island, the Arawak people who inhabited this island moved closer to the shoreline, blissfully unaware of the consequences of this moment as they watched the upcoming ship with fascination. What happened next was to be highly controversial for years to come. Whether you think that the actions Christopher Columbus took were justified or not, you cant deny it paved the way for European settlement in the new world, which shaped world history as we know it. The story of this monumental event was told in two separate passages which both convey different moods and†¦show more content†¦Besides the general length and number of details provided in each piece, I believe this is one of the main differences between the two. The analytical more monotone recount of history with little to no blame or human pe rspective, to a more vivid account of how Columbus and the Spanish interacted with the Native American people. They both had their merits and they both told the story of Christopher Columbuss â€Å"discovery† of America. Though they both were historically accurate, the piece I found the most alluring was Zinn’s because of its depth and human perspective. I felt like Zinn gave a more vivid view of history to the reader; I could imagine the tragedies he was describing and the people he was talking about all because he chose a perspective from which to tell the story. Zinn cited so many primary sources, such as Columbus’s captains logs and Bartolome de las Casas’s written critiques, they were very insightful to read and explained everything in much greater detail than the textbook. Furthermore, I think Zinn’s version was more decisive and less wavering when it comes to Columbuss image. The message was clear: Columbus and other European explorers did h orrible things to the people who inhabited the Americas, although they shaped the modern world, we can not deny that. The text book never really got that profound, in general, I think the textbook seemed to focus more on how the Old World benefited and not the effect it had on the native peoples.Show MoreRelatedPositive Impact Of Christopher Columbus Discoveries1249 Words   |  5 PagesPositive Impact of Christopher Columbus’ Discoveries The world is a better place because of Christopher Columbus’ important discoveries in the New World. His explorations resulted in the vast expansion of property for Europe, the exchange of goods and cultures between countries and a change in the worldview of geography. Columbus’s explorations were the catalyst for unprecedented trade known as the Columbian Exchange, which started the exchange of goods and ideas that would last for centuriesRead MorePositive Impact Of Christopher Columbus s Discoveries1247 Words   |  5 Pages Positive Impact of Christopher Columbus’s Discoveries The world is a better place because of Christopher Columbus’ important discoveries in the New World. His explorations resulted in the vast expansion of property for Europe, the exchange of goods and cultures between countries and a change in the worldview of geography. Columbus’s explorations were the catalyst for unprecedented trade known as the Columbian Exchange, which started the exchange of goods and ideas that would last for centuriesRead MoreThe Positive Effects Of The Columbian Exchange1051 Words   |  5 PagesThe Columbian Exchange The Columbian Exchange was the transfer of plants, animals, human populations, diseases, cultures, and ideas throughout the world. The new worlds that had been discovered were a part of this Columbian Exchange, and were exposed to many new and foreign goods as well as people. The Americas, or New World, were faced with harsh treatment from Columbus and his crew, along with the rampant spread of new diseases that took a large toll on the Native populations. The Indies were alsoRead MoreChristopher Columbus : A Hero Or Hero?1445 Words   |  6 Pages Christopher Columbus was he a hero or was he a villain? As attitudes change throughout the years and new discoveries are being made, history is constantly being rewritten. In the recent years, there has been much controversy over the â€Å"achievements† of the great admiral Christopher Columbus. There have also been many books, articles, and historians that have described him as â€Å"one of the greatest mariners in history, a vis ionary genius, a national hero, a failed administrator, a naive entrepreneurRead MoreLegacy of Christopher Columbus2614 Words   |  11 PagesThe Legacy of Christopher Columbus Abstract After many centuries, a lot of controversy still surrounds Christopher Columbus. He remains to be a strange figure in history regarded as a famous explorer and a great mariner who made many discoveries in his days. Other people still regard him as a visionary and a national hero while others chose to remember him as a brutal and greedy person who used the rest of the humanity for his own selfish gains. Despite the fact that there have been protests inRead MoreThe Columbian Exchange Essay example1077 Words   |  5 PagesThe Columbian Exchange is the exchange of plants, animals, food, and diseases between Europe and the Americas. In 1492, when Christopher Columbus came to America, he saw plants and animals he had never seen before so he took them back with him to Europe. Columbus began the trade routes which had never been established between Europe and the Americas so his voyages initiated the interchange of plants between the Eastern and Western Hemispheres, which doubled the food crop resources available to peopleRead MorePositive And Negative Impacts Of The Columbian Exchange1271 Words   |  6 PagesThe Columbian exchange has helped to double the world’s population between 1650 and 1850. The exchange introduced to the new and old worlds to a variety of things that undoubtedly has shaped the world in time that followed. The Columbian Exchange refers the time that resulted after Christopher Columbus and other explorers discovered the land that would become known as the Americas and many islands, such as Bermuda and the Caribbean. This age of exploration and discovery introduced the newly discoveredRead MoreEffects Of The Columbian Exchange912 Words   |  4 PagesThe biggest exchange that has ever happened in the world was beginning to form from Christopher Columbus’s findings and Pope Alexander’s grant of approval of colonization of Spain over the New World. As it became known as the Columbian Exchange in honor of Columbus, it was the exchange of different plants, animals, microbes, and people across the Atlantic Ocean to the New and Old Worlds. King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella sent out many explorers to the New World which caused both positive and negativeRead MoreThe Impacts of the Columbian Exchange Essay example1338 Words   |  6 PagesThe Columbian Exchange has been called the â€Å"greatest human intervention in nature since the invention of agriculture† (Grennes 2007). The exchange of diseases, plants, and animals lead to a global cultural and economic shift throughout the Old and New Worlds following Christopher Columbus discovery of the Americas in 1492. The Eastern Hemisphere saw an influx of raw materials, new staple crops, and the income from and production of growing crops that were too resource intensive for Europe andRead MoreFlora And Fauna Of The Columbian Exchange1307 Words   |  6 PagesFlora and Fauna in the Columbian Exchange The voyage undertaken by Christopher Columbus to attempt to find a more direct route to India would fail in it s goal. Columbus would not reach India, instead he would land on the banks of a world entirely unknown to Europeans of the time period. His â€Å"discovery† of this New World would have far reaching consequences for both the world he found, and the world from which he departed. This new landmass would prove to be incredibly important in world affairs